An analysis of children should be allowed to testify in court

In the case of abuse, it has been proven young children would rather have a hurtful touch than no touch at all. Great care is given to listening and observing the child.

However, when a child does not wish to testify, then he or she cannot be forced to do so against his or her will. Furthermore, children who give testimony in court are most likely to be older that the ones that Rovee-Collier et al used in their study, and also it is likely that they would have to recall far more detailed information than the colour or arrangement of a mobile.

As an expert witness the counselor can then help the judge understand what has or is happening in such a way as not to damage the child-parent relationship.

Robins et al 92 criticised this investigation on a number of levels and concluded that it could not be applied to support the use of child witnesses in a courtroom situation with any validity. They also confirmed that new, accurate information was recalled ion subsequent interviews.

Preparation for Closed-Circuit Two-Way Testimony Preparation for a closed-circuit two-way testimony of a child, like preparation of any case, is crucial for successful utilization of the procedure.

Generally, judges decide on a case-by-case basis whether a child is competent qualified to testify. There is no requirement that a child be informed of his or her right to express a wish to address the court.

In Florida there is a system called Guardian Ad Litem where a specially trained person who works as a court advocate to speak in the best interest of the child can be assigned to work with a minor child. But, even if a child is subpoenaed ordered to testify and found competent, there are steps the court can take to protect the child from the stress of testifying.

Why Minor Children Should Not Testify Against Their Parents – A personal Opinion

This is under ideal situations, however, which unfortunately rarely occur. A misleading question according to Smith et al, is one that "provides information that is inconsistent with the event witnessed, suggesting, for example, the existence of an object that was in fact not present.

The touch of another human being is essential to life. Positive verbal and physical interaction took place between the confederate and the participant, and positive verbal interaction took place between the confederate and the bystander.

Free Coursework

All judges agreed that children should be allowed to be part of the family law process. Below is a list of equipment used by the State Police for closed-circuit courtroom systems. One of the major problems when assessing the validity of child witnesses is the suggestibility of the child.

Perhaps they knew of one parties misconduct and were asked to help hide it, or at least not disclose it. A misleading question according to Smith et al, is one that "provides information that is inconsistent with the event witnessed, suggesting, for example, the existence of an object that was in fact not present.

What kind of consequences could come from testifying against a parent s? Various questions were asked, which included specific and misleading questions. In their research, the cognitive interview increased the amount of information accurately recalled by children.

Below is some of what the judges said on this topic: Each of us is qualified to a high level in our area of expertise, and we can write you a fully researched, fully referenced complete original answer to your essay question.

Should Children Be Allowed To Testify In Court?

Typically having the children testify should be avoided if it can be. Firstly, the dolls themselves are suggestive.Should Children Be Allowed To Testify In Court? Over the past ten years, more research has been done involving children's testimony than that of all the prior decades combined.

Are children allowed to testify? The short answer is “very rarely, if ever.” Family Court Rule 23 governs the presence or testimony of a child, and its requirements and provisions generally preclude children from testifying in custody cases.

Should Children Be Allowed To Testify In Court?

Child Witness Testimony in Court: Protocol for Using Closed-Circuit Equipment

Over the past ten years, more research has been done involving children's testimony than that of all the prior decades combined. The court may order that the testimony of the child be taken by closed-circuit television if it finds that the child is unavailable to testify in open court in the presence of the defendant, the jury, the judge, and the public for any of the following reasons.

Essay/Term paper: Should children be allowed to testify in court?

Jul 23,  · Children absolutely should be allowed to testify via CCTV. In fact, many states already provide for this where a young child will testify. I think it's very stressful on a child to testify in a courtroom setting (it's stressful on many adults, imagine how a child feels), and this is even more true where the child is the victim of a crime, such 5/5.

Historically children were not allowed to testify directly in court in Orange County, California. The Court used the vehicle of appointing Minor's Counsel to represent the Best Interests of the Child.

Can Children Testify in Court?

This law would change that by allowing direct testimony by a child of sufficient age and maturity to come to court.

Download
An analysis of children should be allowed to testify in court
Rated 0/5 based on 13 review